A portrait of a girl enchants Nathan Tyler so the brothers travel to Salem, Massachusetts, in the year,1692 to find her. While there, Nathan is arrested for kidnapping and Timothy is trapped with a Puritan father who believes him to be his lost son. The townsfolk believe in witchcraft and are suspicious of strangers. Robby races against time trying to save them both. Will he be able to free his siblings and help Nathan find the girl with green eyes?